American Express Platinum Card vs American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card
On an example month of $2,500 in spending, the American Express Platinum Card returns about -$445 a year after its $799 annual fee, and the American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card about -$197 after its $599 annual fee. The American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card comes out about $248 ahead on this budget, before any welcome offer.
Side by side
| Feature | American Express Platinum Card | American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fee | $799 | $599 |
| Network | Amex | Amex |
| Earns | Membership Rewards points | Aeroplan points |
| Groceries | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Dining | 2 points / $1 | 2 points / $1 |
| Gas | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Transit | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Travel | 2 points / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Recurring bills | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Drugstores | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Everything else | 1 point / $1 | 1.25 points / $1 |
| Foreign transaction fee | 2.5% | Not on file |
| Purchase interest rate | Not on file | Not on file |
| Cash advance rate | Not on file | Not on file |
| Minimum income | Not on file | Not on file |
The better figure in each row is in bold. Points rates are compared at the default point value. American Express Platinum Card: 1¢ a point; American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card: 1¢ a point.
Yearly value at different spending levels
| Spending a month | American Express Platinum Card | American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | -$657 | -$438 |
| $2,500 | -$445 | -$197 |
| $5,000 | -$91 | $205 |
A year of rewards minus the annual fee, with spending spread like our example budget (groceries $800, dining $300, gas $200, transit $100, travel $150, recurring bills $250, drugstores $60, everything else $640). Welcome offers and perks such as insurance are not counted.
Your own spending
Welcome offers
- American Express Platinum Card: 70,000 Membership Rewards points after $10,000 of spending in your first 3 months, plus 30,000 points for a purchase between months 15 and 17 of Cardmembership. Worth about $1,000. Issuer page ↗ (checked 2026-10-14)
- American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card: Up to 85,000 Aeroplan points: 60,000 after $7,500 in purchases in the first 3 months, and 25,000 when you spend $2,500 in month 13. Worth about $600. Issuer page ↗ (checked 2026-10-15)
Which one fits you?
Choose the American Express Platinum Card if:
- Most of your spending is on travel.
- You want the larger welcome offer and can reach its minimum spending.
Choose the American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card if:
- Most of your spending is on groceries, gas, transit, recurring bills and drugstores.
- You want a better rate on everything outside the bonus categories.
- You would rather pay a lower annual fee ($599 versus $799).
More comparisons
- American Express Cobalt vs American Express Platinum Card
- American Express Gold Rewards vs American Express Platinum Card
- American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card vs TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege Credit Card
- American Express Platinum Card vs TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege Credit Card
- BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Privilege vs American Express Platinum Card
- American Express Platinum Card vs Scotiabank Platinum American Express Card
Sources
American Express Platinum Card ↗ (checked 2026-10-14) · American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card ↗ (checked 2026-10-15)
Rates summarize the issuer’s published terms on the date shown; confirm them before applying. CardPoints is independent and is not affiliated with any issuer. This is general information, not financial advice.