✳cardpointsCompare your wallet ↗
CREDIT CARD COMPARISON · CANADA

American Express Platinum Card vs American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card

On an example month of $2,500 in spending, the American Express Platinum Card returns about -$445 a year after its $799 annual fee, and the American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card about -$197 after its $599 annual fee. The American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card comes out about $248 ahead on this budget, before any welcome offer.

Side by side

American Express Platinum Card vs American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card
FeatureAmerican Express Platinum CardAmerican Express Aeroplan Reserve Card
Annual fee$799$599
NetworkAmexAmex
EarnsMembership Rewards pointsAeroplan points
Groceries1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Dining2 points / $12 points / $1
Gas1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Transit1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Travel2 points / $11.25 points / $1
Recurring bills1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Drugstores1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Everything else1 point / $11.25 points / $1
Foreign transaction fee2.5%Not on file
Purchase interest rateNot on fileNot on file
Cash advance rateNot on fileNot on file
Minimum incomeNot on fileNot on file

The better figure in each row is in bold. Points rates are compared at the default point value. American Express Platinum Card: 1¢ a point; American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card: 1¢ a point.

Yearly value at different spending levels

Yearly value by monthly spending
Spending a monthAmerican Express Platinum CardAmerican Express Aeroplan Reserve Card
$1,000-$657-$438
$2,500-$445-$197
$5,000-$91$205

A year of rewards minus the annual fee, with spending spread like our example budget (groceries $800, dining $300, gas $200, transit $100, travel $150, recurring bills $250, drugstores $60, everything else $640). Welcome offers and perks such as insurance are not counted.

Your own spending

Yearly value after fees

Welcome offers

Which one fits you?

Choose the American Express Platinum Card if:

Choose the American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card if:

Compare other cards ↗

More comparisons

Sources

American Express Platinum Card ↗ (checked 2026-10-14) · American Express Aeroplan Reserve Card ↗ (checked 2026-10-15)

Rates summarize the issuer’s published terms on the date shown; confirm them before applying. CardPoints is independent and is not affiliated with any issuer. This is general information, not financial advice.