Brim Standard Mastercard vs American Express SimplyCash Card
On an example month of $2,500 in spending, the Brim Standard Mastercard returns about $150 a year with no annual fee, and the American Express SimplyCash Card about $465 with no annual fee. The American Express SimplyCash Card comes out about $315 ahead on this budget, before any welcome offer.
Side by side
| Feature | Brim Standard Mastercard | American Express SimplyCash Card |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fee | None | None |
| Network | Mastercard | Amex |
| Earns | Brim points points | Cash back |
| Groceries | 0.5 points / $1 | 2% cash back |
| Dining | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Gas | 0.5 points / $1 | 2% cash back |
| Transit | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Travel | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Recurring bills | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Drugstores | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Everything else | 0.5 points / $1 | 1.25% cash back |
| Foreign transaction fee | 1.5% | Not on file |
| Purchase interest rate | Not on file | Not on file |
| Cash advance rate | Not on file | Not on file |
| Minimum income | Not on file | Not on file |
The better figure in each row is in bold. Points rates are compared at the default point value. Brim Standard Mastercard: 1¢ a point.
Limits on the bonus rates
- American Express SimplyCash Card: Groceries: 2% cash back up to $15,000 a year, then 1.25% cash back
Yearly value at different spending levels
| Spending a month | Brim Standard Mastercard | American Express SimplyCash Card |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | $60 | $186 |
| $2,500 | $150 | $465 |
| $5,000 | $300 | $899 |
A year of rewards minus the annual fee, with spending spread like our example budget (groceries $800, dining $300, gas $200, transit $100, travel $150, recurring bills $250, drugstores $60, everything else $640). Welcome offers and perks such as insurance are not counted.
Your own spending
Welcome offers
- Brim Standard Mastercard: no current offer in our data.
- American Express SimplyCash Card: A bonus 5% cash back on all purchases in the first 3 months, on up to $2,000 in purchases (up to $100). Worth about $100. Issuer page ↗ (checked 2026-10-15)
Which one fits you?
Choose the American Express SimplyCash Card if:
- Most of your spending is on groceries, dining, gas, transit, travel, recurring bills and drugstores.
- You want a better rate on everything outside the bonus categories.
- You want the larger welcome offer and can reach its minimum spending.
American Express is not accepted everywhere, so check that the places you shop take it.
More comparisons
Sources
Brim Standard Mastercard ↗ (checked 2026-10-15) · American Express SimplyCash Card ↗ (checked 2026-10-15)
Rates summarize the issuer’s published terms on the date shown; confirm them before applying. CardPoints is independent and is not affiliated with any issuer. This is general information, not financial advice.