Is an annual-fee credit card worth it in Canada? How to check the break-even
A card with an annual fee only pays off if the rewards you really earn in a year are bigger than the fee. This guide shows how to work out that break-even point before you decide.
Step 1: Find the break-even spending
Divide the annual fee by the effective rate you would earn on your own spending:
break-even spending = annual fee ÷ effective rate
For example, a $150 fee with an effective rate of 2% needs $7,500 of eligible spending a year before the card returns more than it costs ($150 ÷ 0.02 = $7,500). The fee and rate are illustrations, not figures for any card.
Step 2: Count only the rewards you would really earn
Use your real spending in each category, and apply the rate that category earns. If a card caps its bonus rate, count the spending above the cap at the lower rate. Buying things only to earn rewards usually costs more than the rewards return.
Step 3: Count a welcome offer only once, and only if you can meet it
A welcome offer can change the first-year result, but it applies only in the first year and only when you meet its spending requirement. Check the offer's end date and terms on the issuer's site before you count it.
Step 4: Compare with a no-fee card
The real question is whether the annual-fee card beats the best no-fee card for your spending. Subtract the no-fee card's rewards from the annual-fee card's rewards, then subtract the fee. If the answer is negative, the no-fee card is the better choice on those numbers.
Common mistakes
- Counting spending you would not make anyway.
- Ignoring category caps on the bonus rate.
- Forgetting that a welcome offer is a one-time amount.
- Comparing the fee with the headline rate instead of the rewards you will earn.
Related: the annual-fee check, cards with no annual fee and the full card directory.
Try it with your own numbers: Annual fee break-even calculator ↗
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.