How many credit cards should you have? A two-card method
No single card pays the top rate in every category. A second card can fill the gaps, but each card adds a fee, a payment to track and a credit account. The question is whether the extra rewards are larger than those costs.
The two-card method
- Find the card that earns the most on your largest spending category.
- For each remaining category, see whether another card earns more.
- Add up what the second card would earn on only the categories you would move to it.
- Subtract the second card’s annual fee. If the result is small or negative, one card is enough.
Worked example
A household spends an illustrative $8,000 a year on groceries and $12,000 on everything else. Card A pays an illustrative 4% on groceries and 1% elsewhere. Card B pays an illustrative 2% on everything with no fee.
Card A alone: $320 + $120 = $440. Card A for groceries and card B for the rest: $320 + $240 = $560. The pair earns $120 more a year. These figures are illustrations, not the terms of any card.
What else to weigh
- Acceptance. If one card’s network is not accepted at some stores, the other card covers them.
- Foreign purchases. A card without a foreign transaction fee can be worth keeping for travel and online shopping.
- Fees. Count every annual fee, including fees for additional cardholders.
- Effort. Two cards mean two statements and two payments; automatic full payments remove most of the risk.
When one card is enough
If your spending is concentrated in one category, or modest overall, a single card that pays well on that category, or a flat-rate card, may earn nearly as much with less to manage.
Related: how to calculate rewards on your own spending, foreign transaction fees and compare your wallet.
Try it: Credit card comparison tool.
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.