Points vs cash back in Canada: how to compare them fairly
A card that earns 5 points per dollar and a card that earns 2% cash back can be worth about the same, or very different, depending on what each point is worth to you. This guide puts both on one scale before you compare them.
Step 1: Convert every reward to a cash value
Cash back is already in dollars. Points need a value per point, in cents. The effective earn rate is:
effective rate = points per dollar × value per point (in dollars)
For example, a card that earns 5 points per dollar with each point worth 1 cent returns 5 cents per dollar, or 5%. The same card at 1.5 cents per point returns 7.5%. These values are illustrations, not claims about any card. Use the value you would actually get when you redeem.
CardPoints values each point at 1 cent by default. You can change that value in the app, and each card page states the default it uses.
Step 2: Check the limits
Many cards cap a bonus rate, for example with a monthly or annual spending limit in a category. Above the cap, the card usually earns a lower rate. Compare the rate you will earn on your own spending, not the headline rate.
Step 3: Subtract the annual fee
Net value per year is the rewards you earn in a year minus the annual fee. Example: 00 of rewards less a 50 fee leaves 0. Cards with no fee are compared on rewards alone.
Step 4: Check fees that apply to every purchase
Foreign transaction fees apply to purchases in other currencies and can cancel out a rewards rate on travel or online shopping. Each card page in CardPoints shows the foreign transaction fee on file, and says so where that fee has not been verified yet.
Step 5: Compare on the same basis
Once every card is expressed as a yearly cash value, the ranking is simple. Use the grocery ranking, the annual fee check or the full card directory, then confirm the terms on the issuer's site before you apply.
Common mistakes
- Comparing headline rates without checking the caps.
- Using a point value you have never redeemed at.
- Ignoring the annual fee or the foreign transaction fee.
- Relying on an old point value after a program changes its redemption terms.
Try it: Points value calculator.
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.