Annual fee renewal: keep, downgrade or cancel?
When the annual fee on a card is about to be charged again, you have three options: keep the card, switch to another card from the same issuer, or cancel it. The right choice depends on what the card will earn in the coming year, not on what it earned when you applied.
Step 1: estimate next year’s value
Use your recent spending and the card’s current rates. Do not count the welcome bonus again; it is usually paid once.
next-year value = expected rewards + value of benefits you will use − annual fee
Count a benefit only if you used it last year or will certainly use it this year.
Step 2: compare with a no-fee or lower-fee option
Work out what a no-fee card would earn on the same spending. If the fee card’s next-year value is lower, it is costing you money.
Step 3: ask about a product switch
Many issuers let you move to another of their cards without a new application. Ask what happens to your points, your account history and any fee already charged.
Before you cancel, check
- Points. Some programs forfeit unredeemed points when the card is closed. Redeem or transfer them first if the terms allow.
- Fee refunds. Ask whether the fee is refunded if you cancel soon after it is charged; the terms set the window.
- Credit history. Closing an old account can lower your available credit and the average age of your accounts.
- Insurance and automatic payments. Move recurring bills and confirm you no longer need coverage that came with the card.
Set a reminder
Note the month your fee renews. Reviewing a card a month before renewal gives time to compare options and switch without paying another full fee.
Related: the annual-fee break-even guide, is the annual fee worth it, by card and no-annual-fee cards.
Try it: Annual fee break-even calculator.
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.