Choosing between two credit cards: compare them with your own spending
Two cards can look equally good on their offer pages. The way to decide is to run both through the same calculation using your own spending, not average numbers or headline rates.
Step 1: list your yearly spending by category
Go through two or three recent statements and group what you spent into the categories the cards reward, such as groceries, gas, dining, recurring bills and everything else. Multiply a typical month by 12.
Step 2: calculate each card’s net value
Net yearly value = sum of (yearly spending in a category × reward rate for that category × value of one point or dollar) − annual fee
Check each card’s terms for category spending caps: spending above a cap usually earns the base rate. For points, use a value per point you can realistically get for the redemptions you would actually make.
Worked example
Illustrative spending: $6,000 on groceries and $9,000 on everything else per year.
- Card A: illustrative 3% on groceries and 1% on everything else, no annual fee. $180 + $90 = $270 a year.
- Card B: illustrative 2% on everything and a $120 annual fee. $300 − $120 = $180 a year.
Card A wins for this household by $90 a year, even though Card B’s flat rate looks simpler. With much larger spending outside groceries the answer could flip. These figures are illustrations, not the terms of any card.
Step 3: compare what the formula leaves out
- Welcome offers. Count them once, and only if you will reach the minimum spend with normal purchases.
- Insurance and other benefits. Give them a value only if you would otherwise pay for the same coverage.
- Acceptance and foreign currency fees. A card that is not accepted where you shop, or adds a fee when you travel, earns less than the formula suggests.
- Interest. If you sometimes carry a balance, a lower rate can matter more than any reward.
When to keep both
If each card is clearly better in a different category, holding both and using each where it earns most can beat either one alone, as long as the combined fees still pay for themselves.
Related: annual fee break-even, how many credit cards to have and points value calculator.
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.