Travel rewards for occasional travellers in Canada
If you fly a few times a year, a card with travel rewards can be worth less than its headline rate suggests. The earn rate is only part of the answer. What matters is how many trips you take, what you pay on each one, and whether the rewards you earn on trip spending cover the annual fee.
Count your travel spending, not the headline rate
Start with what you actually spend on travel in a year: flights, hotels, car rentals and transit. Leave out travel you would have paid for with another card anyway, because only the difference is new value from the card.
A simple break-even formula
Net yearly value = rewards earned − annual fee − fees on trip spending
Rewards earned = (travel spend × travel earn rate × value per point) + (other spend × other earn rate × value per point). Fees on trip spending include any foreign transaction fee charged on purchases abroad. If the result is close to zero, the card does not pay for itself at your level of travel, however attractive its rate looks.
Worked example (illustrative)
These figures are illustrations, not the terms of any card. Assume one point is worth one cent, the annual fee is $120, and purchases abroad carry a 2.5% fee.
- Two trips a year, $3,000 of travel spending, $2,000 of it abroad. Travel points: 3,000 × 2 = 6,000. Other spending of $12,000 at 1 point per dollar: 12,000 points. Total 18,000 points × $0.01 = $180 in rewards. Less the $120 fee and 2.5% × $2,000 = $50 foreign fee. Net: $180 − $120 − $50 = $10 a year.
- One trip a year, $1,000 of travel spending, $800 of it abroad. Travel points: 1,000 × 2 = 2,000. Other spending unchanged: 12,000 points. Total 14,000 points × $0.01 = $140. Less the $120 fee and 2.5% × $800 = $20. Net: $140 − $120 − $20 = $0 a year.
In both cases the card barely pays for itself. A traveller who flies less often may be better served by a card with no annual fee and a simple rate, or by the everyday card they already carry.
What the formula can miss
- Whether points expire, and what a redemption for travel really costs compared with the value per point you assumed. See value per point on redemption.
- Whether the card includes travel insurance or other benefits you would otherwise buy. Count them only if you would really pay for them.
- Whether rewards are earned on the full price or only on part of the trip, such as the base fare without taxes and fees. Read the card’s terms.
- Whether the card’s travel category has a cap on bonus points or on spending per year.
A simple rule for occasional travellers
Run the formula with your real figures for the last twelve months. If the net value stays small, a card with no annual fee that earns a steady rate on everyday spending is usually simpler to keep and to manage.
Related: how to calculate rewards on your own spending, the annual fee break-even and points versus cash back.
CardPoints is an independent comparison tool and is not affiliated with these issuers. Rates and terms change, so confirm them on the issuer's site before applying. This is general information, not financial advice.